11 Best Performance Management Software in 2024

Do you know how well your team is performing? A company can only thrive when it has high-performing employees, so it’s vital to have the best performance management software to help you track your team’s strengths and weaknesses.

As a manager or HR professional, it can be challenging to keep track of performance reviews with KPIs, professional development, and additional training for each member of your team. Luckily, performance management software can streamline your processes and automate as many steps as possible to help you stay on top of your team’s progress.

We’ve assembled a list of the best performance management software to aid you in selecting the most suitable one for your business. We’ll delve into the top performance management apps in the US and their pros and cons so you can make an informed decision about which one will benefit your organization the most.

• What is Performance Management Software?
• What Does a Performance Management System Do?
• Benefits of Having a Performance Management System
• 1. Factorial ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
• 2. BambooHR ⭐⭐⭐⭐
• 3. Sage HR ⭐⭐⭐⭐
• 4. Personio ⭐⭐⭐⭐
• 5. CharlieHR ⭐⭐⭐⭐
• 6. Breathe ⭐⭐⭐⭐
• 7. CIPHR ⭐⭐⭐⭐
• 8. HiBob ⭐⭐⭐⭐
• 9. Lattice⭐⭐⭐⭐
• 10. Sesame ⭐⭐⭐⭐
• 11. Leapsome ⭐⭐⭐⭐
• How to Choose Performance Management Software for Your Business

What is Performance Management Software?

Performance management software is a tool that helps companies and managers organize, understand, and manage the performance of their team members. It can be used as a collaborative tool, allowing line managers, heads of departments and HR professionals to access individuals’ records and set strategic goals.

Good performance management software will allow you to track and evaluate performance against KPIs, giving you insight into where individuals need more training and professional development. You’ll usually find features like automated reminders for performance reviews, reporting, goal setting and gamification and rewards for good performance.

What Does a Performance Management System Do?

A performance management system tracks your employees’ performance in a consistent and measurable way. It involves processes that focus on skills, resources and support to maintain and improve employee performance in line with your company goals. Performance management systems also tend to be based on 4 key pillars: planning, monitoring, reviewing and rewarding.

A performance management system aims to plan and establish performance goals in line with organizational objectives, and regularly monitor and review your team’s progress through 360-degree feedback. A good performance management system also rewards high-performing or much-improved staff members through employee recognition programs.

Benefits of Having a Performance Management System

There are plenty of benefits to having a performance management system and software to support it:

• Higher retention: Having all your performance management resources organized and centralized will allow you to give regular feedback to your team members, helping them to develop their skills, progress their careers and therefore feel more valued. You should notice a reduction in employee turnover.
• Increased engagement: Your staff are more likely to be engaged with their work if they know that you’re invested in improving their performance and professional development.
• Builds trust: You’ll have better relationships with your team members if you’re having regular appraisals and check-ins with them.
• Better business performance: Your organization is more likely to meet its objectives, as your teams will know what they need to do to be successful in their roles and should all be working towards the same overall goals.

So, now we know what performance management software is and its benefits, let’s look at the best options on the market to help you choose the right one for your business.

1. Factorial ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Flexible performance management software with automation, templates and tracking to get the most out of your team.

Overview

Factorial’s performance management software offers a complete solution for small and medium businesses for efficiently tracking and managing employee performance. You can take control of your performance reviews, using Factorial’s suggested questions to save time or writing your own in various formats to create a customized plan for your business.

With Factorial, you’ll gain insight into every level of your workforce by assigning the best reviewers for each individual, and you can even automate the process so performance reviews are sent out monthly, yearly, or on your own timescale. Having a centralized place to store your evaluations and responses alongside all your other HR data ensures you can oversee the review process effectively while also protecting your team members’ confidentiality.

Pros

✅Intuitive and easy-to-use interface
✅Use suggested performance review questions or write your own
✅Automatically include new hires in the performance review cycle
✅Integrated with analytics, so you can run custom reports such as group performance data by team
✅Facilitates the entire performance cycle, from identifying competencies to reviews to reports

Cons

❌No app for PC, so you can only use the web-based version and mobile app
❌Best suited to small to medium-sized businesses, with accessibility for larger enterprises coming soon

User reviews

Customers love that performance management is just one part of the Factorial app, and that you can centralize all your HR processes such as onboarding, time tracking and document management. Its holistic approach to HR means that rather than performance management becoming just another one of your jobs to do, it becomes an easy, automated part of your processes to enhance business performance rather than bog you down.

Performance Management Features

1. Flexible performance review options

To keep performance reviews fair, it’s best to use mostly the same questions for each employee. But every business is different – so you still need the option to write your own performance review questions.

With Factorial, you can use our suggested questions and write your own, then save them so they’re ready for the next round of appraisals. Plus, you can choose whether the answers are optional or mandatory and whether they will be submitted anonymously.

2.  Automation

Take the effort out of performance management with automated email notifications when it’s time for appraisals to take place. There’s no need to upload data to Factorial as all feedback is submitted directly through Factorial, keeping everything centralized and organized. Set automated cycles for appraisals on a monthly, yearly or customized basis – whatever suits your team.

3. Centralize your data

Keep your performance appraisals alongside the rest of your HR data so you can check in on the review process whenever you need to. You’ll see the status of each evaluation with a progress tracker so you know whether your reviews are running on time.

Your line managers and other reviewers can edit questions and review comments as they come in straight from the platform, so there’s a record of everything all in one place.

4. Workforce insights and integration

Easily get 360 feedback for individuals by creating dynamic groups of reviewers. You can assign specific team members or even the entire company to give feedback on particular individuals. And with the option to add new hires into the performance review process and new supervisors whenever necessary, you’ll never lose track of your team’s progress.

5. Custom reporting

Use Factorial’s custom reports to track employee development and identify where team members need to improve. You can group data by office or team to pinpoint strengths and weaknesses and help you make informed decisions with quantitative and qualitative data.

6. Store meeting notes within the app

Make notes during performance reviews and store them in Factorial so you can view them before the next meeting. Set agendas to help keep your appraisals on track and to ensure you cover everything you want to with your team members.

7. Track employee development and skills

Use Factorial to detect training needs and create an action plan of training that needs to take place. View employee progress as they complete training sessions and courses and track how effective they are so you can make adjustments if you need to.

Pricing

Prices vary depending on choice of bundle.
Request a demo with a Factorial expert to find out more.

2. BambooHR ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Good automation of performance review reminders, but lacks customization of the performance evaluation process and questions.

Overview

BambooHR is an HR software solution that’s aimed at medium to large enterprises. Its performance management system comes as an add-on to its main software, and this can be expensive for small businesses that might not need to use all of the features right now.

BambooHR lets you create multiple performance review cycles with different scheduling so you can customize your reviews based on department. You can also schedule and automate reminders for 30-, 60- and 90-day check-ins with new hires to help integrate them into their roles and the business. However, you’ll have to use BambooHR’s standard appraisal questions – you can’t customize them for your business.

Pros

✅ Easy-to-use interface
✅ Allows you to manage many HR processes in one software
✅ Schedule review cycles with up to four formal reviews each year, with the option to add and automate informal check-ins

Cons

❌ Unable to customize performance review questions specific to your company
❌ Limited reports available for performance management
❌ Can be expensive due to bundles

User reviews

Users are overall satisfied with BambooHR, but its performance management add-on regularly features as a weakness in reviews. You can’t customize performance review questions, leaving users frustrated that they can’t tailor their appraisals to the goals and objectives of their company. BambooHR’s pricing structure also means that it is one of the more expensive options for businesses that have just over 20 employees.

Pricing

Priced on a per-month basis for companies below 20 employees, then a per-employee, per-month basis for companies with 20 employees or more.

3. Sage HR ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Best for medium-to-large companies that want to track individuals’ contributions to specific KPIs, but lacks a modern user interface.

Overview

Sage HR is one of Sage’s many business software solutions. It’s aimed at medium-to-large companies and scale-ups and integrates with all other Sage software as well as some third-party options.

The key benefit of Sage HR’s performance management system is that it encourages using OKRs (objectives and key results) to track and measure individual performance. You can see how close a team member is to completing a goal or skill on a bar chart that updates with a percentage as tasks are ticked off. However, its tools for performance management don’t have the modern feel that a lot of other HR software has and can be expensive if you need all the add-ons.

Pros

✅Offers 1-to-1 meeting scheduling within the app
✅Gives you the ability to measure employee engagement through anonymous surveys
✅Has a ‘quick praise’ option for teams to congratulate each other for good work easily

Cons

❌Users find that the software isn’t intuitive to use
❌Interface isn’t as modern-looking as other platforms
❌Designed to be used with other Sage solutions, so integration with other software is difficult

User reviews 

Users like Sage HR because it integrates with its other solutions, such as payroll and invoicing. But they don’t have much to say about their performance management add-on. Overall, HR professionals and business owners using Sage HR praise its reporting functions but say that it lacks customization for certain workflows. They also say it’s expensive if you want the performance management add-on plus other options like timesheets, ATS and expenses.

Pricing

You’ll pay $6 per user per month for access to Sage HR Core and the performance management add-on. If you want to use its other features, such as recruitment and shift scheduling, it can cost up to $11 per user plus $160 per month.

4. Personio ⭐⭐⭐⭐

A good option for small businesses, but users note that when using Personio’s performance management software, they often encounter technical issues and it can be slow to load.

Overview

Personio’s key selling point is that it automates processes to help HR teams free up time for more strategic work. It prevents missed or late performance reviews as it lets employees know when they need to fill in their appraisal forms and reminds managers when it’s time to conduct the reviews.

Personio lets you create standardized staff appraisal forms to ensure that you ask all employees the same questions, allowing for fair reviews. With standardized rating scales, you can visualize these ratings across teams and see where management as well as individuals need to make improvements.

Pros

✅Set up performance cycles for your entire company or for individual teams and automatically remind employees to complete their reviews
✅Standardized appraisal forms and rating scales to allow for fair reviews
✅Link targets to bonus payments and automatically add them to payroll when met

Cons

❌Tools for performance management are new and are still in development
❌The platform is sometimes slow to load
❌No option to allow anonymous feedback
❌While standardized forms allow for fair reviews, the lack of customization means some businesses find it difficult to tailor appraisals to their business goals

User review

Personio users love that they can keep all their HR data in one place and that all the features integrate well with each other. It’s also intuitive to use and managers say that they didn’t have to provide much training to their teams on how to use it. However, many reviews state that the platform is sometimes slow to load and that it can be difficult to drill down into detail on reports. Lots of users say that the system and tools for performance management still need to be improved.

Pricing

Only available by quote, but the performance management system is offered as an add-on, meaning you’ll pay extra to access it.

5. CharlieHR ⭐⭐⭐⭐

A strong choice for smaller businesses, but won’t scale with you as your business grows.

Overview

CharlieHR is aimed at small businesses, automating various HR tasks and offering easy-to-launch performance reviews. There’s one price for the entire software, meaning you might pay for features that you don’t use.

CharlieHR has all the features you’d expect it to have, including 360 feedback, guided processes for managers and insight into progress. However, if your business expands rapidly, you could grow out of the software quite quickly. Reporting and analytics are limited, and managers find that it’s hard to bulk-upload data.

Pros

✅Simple and easy-to-use interface
✅Easy setup for reviews and automated reminders
✅Get an overview of employee progress on the dashboard
✅Allows for 360 feedback to get a holistic view of how an individual is progressing

Cons

❌Sometimes notifications don’t show up, meaning managers and employees can miss appraisal reminders
❌Reporting and analytics could be more in-depth
❌It’s difficult to bulk-upload custom data, so once businesses scale up, they may look for another solution

User reviews 

Overall, users are happy with CharlieHR. It offers most features that small businesses need, and HR managers and business leaders find it easy to set up reviews with automated reminders. The interface is simple and intuitive, and most reviewers state that they have no trouble navigating the menus.

However, it’s clear that CharlieHR is focusing on small businesses, so once companies begin to grow and need better analytics, reporting and bulk-upload functions, they may find that they outgrow this performance management software. Transitioning to another platform when you’ve already got lots of data can be time-consuming and leave you open to breaches of confidentiality if not done correctly, so it’s worth bearing in mind.

Pricing

$4 per user per month

6. BreatheHR ⭐⭐⭐⭐

A comprehensive performance management system for small to medium-sized businesses, but struggles with integration and automation.

Overview

Breathe is an HR solution that is best suited to SMEs. Its performance management system is part of its Core HR package, and offers features like in-app performance review booking, training courses and goal setting. Its interface is simple and intuitive, allowing you and your team to get started quickly.

But like CharlieHR, Breathe struggles with scalability. Users note problems with API integration and find that they can’t customize reports and workflows enough. There’s also a lack of automation and email notifications in the Core HR package.

Pros

✅Intuitive and easy to use
✅Ability to add specific training courses for individuals
✅Score employee performance and compare with other team members

Cons

❌No email notifications for scheduled performance reviews
❌Users report intermittent issues with integrations
❌No bulk-upload feature

User reviews

Breathe users love how simple it is to use and how you can keep all your HR operations in one place. Many reviews mention being able to add training courses for each team member, and that the dashboard is easy to read and understand. However, reviewers also commonly complain that the performance management software isn’t customizable, making it difficult to add business-specific appraisal questions. Like CharlieHR, once businesses outgrow Breathe, they may have to go through the hassle of transferring to another performance management system.

Pricing

Plans start at $13 per month for businesses of 1-10 people, with additional modules starting at $6 per month.

7. CIPHR ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Great for succession planning, but can be slow to load and difficult to use.

Overview

CIPHR prides itself on offering detailed HR metrics to help you with succession planning and talent development. It allows you to add nine-box grid criteria and then enables you to build talent pools for your business-critical roles. It can auto-populate talent pools with a role’s direct reports if those people satisfy your minimum nine-box grid criteria, reducing the time it takes to assess your team’s skills.

Pros

✅ Good product support
✅ Customization available
✅ Easy to access on mobile as well as PC

Cons

❌ Can be slow to load
❌ Not always easy to use, with some sections of the app difficult to navigate
❌ Learning how to create your own reports is tricky
❌ It’s expensive

User reviews

Users speak highly of CIPHR’s customer support and onboarding, and that the software is customizable so you can make it relevant to your business. However, users also mention that reporting can be tricky to learn if you’ve not got strong Excel skills. Customers also say that the platform is expensive as you have to pay for each part of the performance management software as an add-on.

Pricing

Only available on request, but the performance management system is offered as an add-on, meaning you’ll pay extra to access it.

8. HiBob ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Intuitive and easy to use, but performance review flows need work.

Overview

HiBob is an all-in-one HR system whose main USP is that you have everything you need to conduct 360-degree performance reviews, giving you a complete timeline of each employee’s career with the organization, goals and achievements, so each manager can conduct a fair review.

Pros

✅ Highly intuitive user interface
✅ Integrates with other software such as Slack
✅ Easy to set goals and growth plans to develop employees

Cons

❌ No way to add non-anonymous feedback or surveys
❌ One-to-one flows need improvement
❌ Some reports are difficult to access
❌ Not suitable for larger enterprises

User reviews

Customers love how user-friendly Bob is and how it takes very little training for team members to be able to use the software. They also like that lots of parts of it can be customized, and the mobile app performs well. However, many users mention that they would like to see better integration with calendars such as Google and Outlook so they could send out automatic calendar invites for performance reviews or one-to-ones. There’s also no way for employees to request one-to-ones: only a line manager can request them.

Pricing

Only available on request.

9. Lattice⭐⭐⭐⭐

A cohesive performance management software, but delays in deployment frustrates customers.

Overview

Lattice is an all-in-one performance management software that brings together workflows for performance management, employee engagement surveys, compensation management, and career development. You can update OKRs and goals as and when you need to, and link individual goals to team goals, so everyone is working towards the same aim. You can also store 1:1 performance evaluation notes within the app that you can refer back to whenever you need them.

Pros

✅ Very easy to use
✅ Range of survey functions, including for on/offboarding and engagement
✅ Easy to construct your own performance review cycles

Cons

❌ Surveys aren’t 100% anonymous
❌ Slow to deploy new features and misses deadlines
❌ Some users say reports are unorganized
❌ Hard to add two managers for one employee

User reviews 

Customers say that Lattice is very easy to use and that the human focus of the software gives it an edge. Users also like how customizable the platform is, allowing you to add your own workflows, cycles, and survey questions. However, many customers complain that they have missed deadlines on new feature deployments.

Pricing

$11 per person per month for the basic package, with additional bundles from $4 per person per month.

10. Sesame ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Customizable and flexible to an organization’s needs, but can be difficult to use and the mobile app needs work.

Overview

Sesame says that it allows companies to digitize their HR processes by simplifying and automating them. Its performance management system allows you to make custom questionnaires, schedule your performance evaluations and view information in visual graphs to help you analyze performance across your team.

Pros

✅ Easy to implement
✅ Get a visual representation of key information
✅ Choose between 90, 180, 270 or 360-degree feedback

Cons

❌ Not very intuitive
❌ Mobile app often crashes
❌ Slow customer support

User reviews 

Customers that use Sesame mainly praise it on its time tracking and leave request features rather than its performance management system. They say that it’s great to be able to view information in a variety of formats and that you can choose who is giving feedback during performance reviews. However, many users also mention that the mobile app crashes, the dashboard can be confusing to use and there is a lack of administrator permissions, which means lower-level employees could make changes.

Pricing

€5.25 per user per month for Sesame HR Professional, which includes the performance management system.

11. Leapsome ⭐⭐⭐⭐

A comprehensive tool with excellent templates and customizable modules, but UX is clunky.

Overview

Leapsome is HR software that aims to drive performance, increase engagement, and automate processes. You can use performance review templates to suit your business and use their analytics to gain insight into your team’s performance, as well as conduct project, leadership or 360-degree feedback reviews.

Pros

✅ Great customer support
✅Integrates with a range of other software
✅ Customizable dashboard to allow you to see the information that’s important to you

Cons

❌ Some find the UX clunky
❌ No dark mode feature
❌ Some find the graphs difficult to interpret

User reviews 

Leapsome is loved for its feedback loops and customizable performance reviews, with lots of praise for its competency matrix. However, users sometimes find the UX clunky – there is no auto-login feature and some tabs are placed in counter-intuitive places. Plus, it can be tricky to interpret data from complex graphs.

Pricing

Only available on request.

How to Choose Performance Management Software for Your Business

Now you’ve seen our picks for the best performance management software, you’ll need to make a decision on which one is best for your business. With so many performance management systems to choose from, it can be hard to make that final decision.

Follow our steps to help you choose the right performance management software for your company:

• Consider your needs: What features must your performance management software have? Which ones would be nice to have?
• Explore other features: Look at what other tools for performance management the software has. Could these add value to your business? Can the software grow with you as you expand?
• Check integrations: Ensure that your performance management software will integrate with your other software, such as payroll and expenses software.
• Consider cost: Remember that cheapest doesn’t always mean best. It’s important to find a solution that fits with your budget, but ensure that the performance management software you choose will function correctly for your business and that you won’t have to sacrifice features or usability for a cheaper product.

Try Factorial’s Performance Management Software for free!